“Agnes of God” – Lace Market Theatre

“Immediately absorbing […] will make you question all different aspects of life, death and religion”

When a young nun is found with a dead baby in her room, psychologist Doctor Livingstone (Delara Baria Mitchell) is sent to assess her, and determine whether she should be imprisoned, sectioned or acquitted. Immediately, this is a fascinating set-up, and the play wastes no time in introducing us to our three characters, who each have their own secrets that get revealed across the course of the two hour runtime. There are elements of mystery here – at times you may find yourself wondering “who’s the daddy” – but “Agnes of God”, written by John Pielmeier, is more a psychological study than a twisty-turny plot, slowly breaking down each character to allow us to understand why they have made certain choices, and how their pasts have shaped their futures.

The poster for the play

Mitchell commands the stage throughout as Livingstone, a forceful presence who is more than a match for Monica Dakin’s Mother Superior Miriam. Livingstone is hardly an impartial observer – glimpses into her past, performed as monologues directly to the audience, show her disdain for Catholicism and her sheer distrust of nuns. It immediately sets Livingstone up in contest with Miriam, and this is a true clash of the titans at points, yet they manage to find some common ground, and there are some quieter moments played between them. Such is the nature of this play; the relationships between the characters are constantly evolving, as we peel back the many layers that construct these complicated characters.

Miriam is introduced as harsh and strict, yet there is something more rebellious hiding beneath the surface – in her first scene, we learn that she was a smoker and is not afraid to use bad language, and rest assured there are plenty more secrets to come out about the Mother Superior as the play continues. Dakin also manages to find some elements of comedy in her abrupt responses to Livingstone’s questions – when Miriam suggests that maybe the baby didn’t have a father, but was rather born of a miracle, Dakin’s utter seriousness cannot help but raise a few laughs from the audience.

Monica Dakin as Mother Superior, Delara Baria Mitchell as Doctor Livingstone and Fiona Bumann as Agnes. Photo credit: Grace Eden Photography.

The plot kicks into gear when we are introduced to Fiona Bumann’s Agnes, the nun at the centre of this story, who claims to not remember the birth or even have any recollection of the baby. We are not sure whether she is lying about this, or whether she has blocked out some sort of trauma, and Bumann plays it perfectly, giving us just enough to question the story without spoiling the reveals that come later. There is a simple innocence to Agnes that Bumann portrays with a beautiful stillness, a fearful determination feeding in to her delivery. This is interjected with sudden outbursts as Livingstone forces Agnes to relive her past. These moments are harrowing, again testament to Bumann’s excellent portrayal.

Lace Market’s intimate studio theatre feels like the perfect setting for such an intricate character study, although one might hope for a little more eye contact from the characters, particularly from Mitchell, who delivers her monologues above our heads rather than directly to the audience. ÓGC’s lighting design makes use of a faintly pulsing light during flashback scenes, and lights Bumann in a cold blue wash when she begins to sing (the play is often punctuated with Latin hymns), which makes Agnes feel reminiscent of a ghost, incredibly appropriate given that Agnes is haunted by many ghosts, including that of her mother and her baby. There are other moments where the lighting shifts dramatically without really warranting such a change – for instant, one scene in which Livingstone and Miriam share a cigarette on the chaise longue sees the lighting suddenly switch from harsh white to soft gold, yet there is no change in scene or time of day. The change emphasises the shift in mood rather than time and place, although as such it would be nice if the transition were less abrupt.

Delara Baria Mitchell as Doctor Livingstone and Monica Dakin as Mother Superior. Photo credit: Grace Eden Photography.

Pielmeier’s script can feel a little circular and repetitive at times, mostly due to the fact that both Agnes and Miriam seem determined to stick to their story, and it takes a long time for Livingstone to make them crack, although this does mean that when the truth is finally revealed, it definitely feels earned, and thankfully the reveals do not disappoint. There are some fairly graphic (and one may say gratuitous) descriptions of sexual assault, although these are accompanied with more poetic recollections, which leave an even worse taste in the mouth – which is, of course, the desired effect. This is certainly an uncomfortable watch at times, but all handled with utmost care in the hands of director Sammy Whitworth.

This is a play of such depth that it is clear to see the time and effort that has gone into understanding and realising these characters. The story is immediately absorbing, and will make you question all different aspects of life, death and religion. The three actors here are at the top of their game, and create a world that will quickly suck you in, so that even when the plot becomes a little strained (there are some questionable moments in the second act involving hypnosis), we remain compelled thanks to the characters. Another hit for Lace Market Theatre.

Tom Morley, November 2026

Fiona Bumann as Agnes. Photo credit: Grace Eden Photography.

Review Round-up:

Kev Castle Theatre Reviews: Agnes of God – Kev’s write-up points calls the play “harrowing and incredibly moving”, summarising by saying “it’s powerful stuff!”